From Oak Bluffs to West Tisbury: Beautiful Boutique Hotels in Martha’s Vineyard

From the Edgartown Collection hotels to the secluded hideaways tucked into the island’s picturesque landscapes, Martha’s Vineyard offers a diverse array of boutique hotel experiences that capture the essence of New England charm. Each establishment, unique in its ambiance and offerings, invites visitors to immerse themselves in the island’s rich culture, history, and natural beauty. Whether you’re drawn to the elegance of meticulously restored historic properties or the cozy allure of a modern retreat, Martha’s Vineyard’s boutique hotels promise an unforgettable stay tailored to every traveler’s desire for luxury, comfort, and authentic local experiences. This guide explores the finest accommodations the island has to offer, ensuring your next visit to Martha’s Vineyard is nothing short of extraordinary. Read on to find the perfect place before you book your next guest room in Cape Cod.

Romantic Ocean Views, Rich History, and Incredible Eats: Why We Love Martha’s Vineyard

Martha’s Vineyard, an island off the coast of Massachusetts, attracts people for a myriad of reasons, ranging from its scenic beauty and rich history to its unique culture and community events.

The island’s charm lies in its ability to offer something for everyone, from tranquil beaches to lively cultural festivals.

Stunning Natural Beauty

One of the primary draws of Martha’s Vineyard is its natural beauty. With miles of pristine beaches, such as those at South Beach, Lambert’s Cove, and Aquinnah, the island offers endless opportunities for relaxation and water activities.

The varied landscape also includes lush forests and scenic cliffs, particularly noticeable at the Gay Head Cliffs in Aquinnah, offering breathtaking views of the ocean and sunsets. Outdoor enthusiasts enjoy biking along the Shining Sea Bikeway, hiking in the Manuel F. Correllus State Forest, and exploring the numerous conservation lands.

Events and Gatherings

Cultural events and community gatherings are another significant attraction. The island hosts numerous festivals and events throughout the year, including the famous Martha’s Vineyard Film Festival, the Agricultural Fair, and the Grand Illumination Night, which celebrates the community’s history and culture with lanterns, music, and dance.

The Vineyard’s dining scene also draws visitors, offering a range of options from casual seafood shacks to fine dining establishments, many of which feature locally sourced ingredients and seafood.

Rich History and Culture

Beyond its natural attractions, Martha’s Vineyard is steeped in rich history and culture. The island’s towns, like Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, and Vineyard Haven, each have their distinct character, from the stately whaling captains’ homes in Edgartown to the colorful gingerbread cottages in Oak Bluffs.

The island’s history is closely tied to the sea, and visitors can learn about its maritime heritage at the Martha’s Vineyard Museum or by visiting the island’s historic lighthouses.

Artistic Retreats That Enrich the Island

Moreover, Martha’s Vineyard has long been a retreat for artists, writers, and celebrities, drawn by the island’s secluded yet vibrant community life. This blend of natural beauty, cultural richness, and a strong sense of community makes Martha’s Vineyard a unique destination that captivates visitors year after year. It’s a great location for anyone seeking an escape to island life.

These Are the Loveliest Martha’s Vineyard Hotels for Your Trip to Cape Cod

The Sydney

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Sydney Carver Snyder (@summerwind41490)

Nestled in the elegant surroundings of Edgartown, The Sydney provides a chic and comfortable stay. With its prime location, guests can enjoy easy access to the best of what Edgartown has to offer, from galleries and restaurants to the tranquil waterside. The Sydney is praised for its stylish rooms and exceptional service, making it a sought-after destination for travelers looking for a blend of luxury and local charm​.

The Lightkeepers Inn

The Lightkeeper’s Inn in Martha’s Vineyard is a charming boutique hotel that offers a cozy and intimate lodging experience in Edgartown. Its location is perfect for guests looking to explore the local area, including nearby restaurants, shops, and beautiful beaches. The inn provides a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere for visitors, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a tranquil retreat on the island.

The Franklin Hotel, Martha’s Vineyard

The Franklin Hotel in Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard, offers a modern and chic lodging experience with 18 guestrooms designed to delight every sense. Its prime location on Upper Main Street means it’s just a short walk from the heart of the historic village and its renowned beaches. The hotel’s design incorporates artful elements that pay homage to the local neighborhood, providing a fresh take on nautical style with modern, luxury finishes.

The Edgar Hotel

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Edgar Hotel (@edgarhotelmv)

The Edgar Hotel Martha’s Vineyard, part of the Ascend Hotel Collection, offers a distinctive and elegant experience in Edgartown. This newly updated hotel delivers comfort and impeccable accommodations, centrally located to downtown and the island’s attractions. It boasts tastefully renovated rooms and suites with modern comforts in a relaxed island atmosphere, including free Wi-Fi and deluxe bath amenities. The hotel’s full-service restaurant, TownBar MV, is a popular spot for casual dining

The Christopher

Also situated in Edgartown, The Christopher stands out with its grand gabled homestead style. Tucked away on a leafy side street, this boutique hotel offers a serene retreat amidst the vibrant atmosphere of Martha’s Vineyard. The Christopher is celebrated for its luxurious accommodations and personalized service, providing a peaceful haven for its guests​.

Nobnocket Boutique Inn

This award-winning inn set in Vineyard Haven is known for its modern interior design and expansive outdoor space. Offering a luxury retreat away from the crowds, Nobnocket Boutique Inn features sumptuous Frette linens, luxury toiletries, and contemporary amenities. Its secluded setting on 2 acres of gardens offers guests a unique island experience, with the option to enjoy their vacation without ever leaving the comfort of the property.

Hob Knob

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Hob Knob Luxury Boutique Hotel (@hobknobmv)

Embodying classic Gothic Revival architecture, Hob Knob offers a luxurious boutique hotel experience in Edgartown. For nearly 100 years, it has provided exceptional personal service and comfort. Guests can enjoy modern amenities, charming décor, and the leisurely seaside lifestyle that Martha’s Vineyard is famous for. Its location allows for easy exploration of historic museums, delicious seafood, and a variety of outdoor adventures​.

Summercamp Hotel

Transforming an old Methodist summer camp into a funky and vibrant boutique hotel, Summercamp Hotel in Oak Bluffs captures the essence of childhood nostalgia while offering elegance and style. Ideal for families and those looking to explore the town and coastline, it provides a characterful base with plenty of activities and a funky ambiance​.

The Richard

Located in Edgartown, The Richard is a boutique hotel that combines modern amenities with historical charm. Offering free WiFi, flat-screen TVs, private bathrooms, and a grab-and-go continental breakfast, it ensures guests have a comfortable and convenient stay. The hotel’s serene atmosphere and tasteful decorations make it a prime choice for travelers seeking both relaxation and modern convenience​​.

Harbor View Hotel

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Harbor View Hotel (@harborviewhotel)

With marvelous views of Edgartown Lighthouse, Harbor View Hotel offers an unforgettable stay just minutes away from downtown Edgartown. This boutique hotel features an on-site restaurant, two bars, and a variety of amenities including an outdoor pool and concierge services. Its charming design and convenient location make it a favorite among visitors looking for a blend of luxury and local exploration​​.

Faraway Martha’s Vineyard

Offering a fresh take on the boutique hotel experience, Faraway Martha’s Vineyard stands out for its unique style and relaxed atmosphere. Located conveniently to allow guests to explore the beauty of Martha’s Vineyard, Faraway provides a blend of comfort and adventure. It’s a perfect spot for those looking to enjoy the island’s natural beauty and serene lifestyle.

The Edgartown Inn

The Edgartown Inn is a charming and historic Martha’s Vineyard hotel. It provides a cozy and inviting atmosphere, reflecting the quintessential New England charm. This inn is conveniently located, offering guests easy access to explore the beauty and attractions of the area.

The Harborside Inn

The Harborside Inn, situated on the harbor in Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard, offers a prime waterfront location and is considered the island’s premier waterfront resort. With 90 guest rooms that feature luxury amenities, including a heated waterfront pool adjacent to Edgartown Harbor, this Martha’s Vineyard hotel is the perfect destination for those seeking both relaxation and adventure. Some rooms even offer balcony views of the harbor, allowing guests to enjoy the picturesque surroundings. Its location also puts Edgartown Village’s finest art galleries, dining, shops, and nightlife just a short stroll away.

The Attleboro House

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by The Attleboro House (@attleborohouse)

The Attleboro House in Martha’s Vineyard offers a unique blend of modern conveniences and historic charm. Situated among the iconic Gingerbread Cottages and directly on Oak Bluffs harbor, it provides stunning views and easy access to local shops, restaurants, and beaches. Following a complete renovation in 2018, the inn now features standard and deluxe guest rooms with modern amenities, offering a one-of-a-kind experience in an original gingerbread cottage​.

Where Will You Stay?

As this article ends, we’re reminded of the island’s unparalleled ability to blend the comfort of luxury accommodations with the charm of its storied past and vibrant natural setting. Each hotel we’ve explored offers its own unique narrative, contributing to the arts, culture, and scenic beauty that makes Martha’s Vineyard not just a destination, but an experience. From the opulent Edgartown Collection to the Mansion House Inn to the tranquil retreats within walking distance of the beach, these boutique hotels stand as gateways to the essence of Martha’s Vineyard, inviting every traveler to find their own slice of paradise.

Whether you’re seeking adventure, relaxation, or a touch of New England’s historical elegance, Martha’s Vineyard’s boutique hotels are ready to welcome you to an unforgettable escape. Looks like it’s time to pack your beach towels and prep for check in! Where will you stay? Let us know in the comments below!